I watched that episode again last night, I felt sorry for Hershel this time

_________________

Hershel is a mong, I know theres a cure for them They should send him to atlanta and see if he can save them all there too

_________________

I felt sorry for Hershel, too.

Sure his way of thinking was completely the wrong way, but to him he saw his family members getting shot as they came out of that barn.

A question about the last episode. When Hershel knew that everyone knew about the barn, why didn't he tell them they had caught and put a little girl in there?

Because he's a dick and didn't want them to know.

_________________

The Eeveelution club! \o/

They never described what she looked like, and nobody knew he was herding zombies

Plus like goat said he's a dick

_________________

Read on another forum that Hershel mentioned to Rick that Otis was the one that rounded up the zombies and brought them back to the barn. So it's plausible that he would have had no clue.

Edit. Boo

_________________

I bet he did know and is just a massive troll. Making them go out looking for her knowing she was in the barn all that time.

_________________

The Eeveelution club! \o/

Awesome episode. Shame it's gonna be ages to the next one.

_________________

This show has so many plot holes it defies any serious attempt to suspend disbelief; the acting is, at best barely passable; I frequently find myself WILLING the story to get a move on, please; as has been said, none of them can see past 10ft w or w/o binoculars... Yet for all of that, this is the most compelling television I've watched since Lost. A very good end to the (mid) season.

Quite a few of the characters are clearly, at this point, redundant, with black guy and abused-widow/mom in particular seeing NO development AT ALL. Perhaps their time us coming, but I doubt it.

Think you should probably broaden your TV viewing then.

_________________
A Torrent of Thoughts

Was the best episode of season 2

_________________

Currently Playing: FIFA13, Skyrim, The Last of Us, Final Fantasy XIV Beta
The RPG Thread | Film Club 13 | Top Gear | Celebrity Women

Yes, I think that, too. It's also the group's 'get out of jail' card to use against Herschel - for a 'man of God' that was low-down dirty thing to do to them all. His reasoning will be doubtless that had he told them, he knew full well what they would do to her (which they promptly did), but even so, by keeping quiet about her, assuming he did know, any moral ground he might have had has now been lost.

Great episode - very compelling viewing and expertly made - never once veered into cheesiness and that is no easy thing to achieve when you're essentially driving a story as fanciful and bonkers as this. Shane continues to impress (his strongest episode yet - the face-off with Dale at the swamp was great and I loved Dale's line about how Shane 'belonged in a world like this'; great writing and acting), but above all I like the entire series' tone and style. I also think the opening titles for the series are some of the best around.

Can't wait for more.

_________________
"Nothing is the cause of a phenomenon in the presence of which the phenomenon fails to occur."

I might not be the first to notice this but everytime I see Dale, I picture the guy from Toy Story in my head.

I dont; know why but i have trouble remembering anyone's name in this show

_________________

me to, i remeber rick, shane, lori and dale for some reason.

_________________

This.

_________________

Check this out. What might have been in season 2 had Frank been allowed to continue!

http://www.aintitcool.com/node/52526

That sounds really awesome. What a shame.

_________________
A Torrent of Thoughts

I like the titles but Boardwalk Empires steals it for me.

_________________